Skip to content

The Harvard Gazette s8视频app下载手机版

On the brink of war衢州永元利商贸有限公司

抖阴直播污app在线下载 Unlearning racial bias 北海多飞金科技有限公司

National & World Affairs 义乌金千中贸易有限公司



National & World Affairs 铁岭巨厚祥设备有限公司


Mourners attend the funeral procession of Maj. Gen. Qassim Suleimani, who was killed in a drone attack on Friday.

Reuters/Abdullah Dhiaa al-Deen


The killing of Maj. Gen. Qassim Suleimani, a powerful figure in Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, in a drone attack Friday ordered by President Trump has triggered a cascade of potentially incendiary consequences.

In the days after the deadly attack Trump exchanged retaliatory threats with Iranian officials on social media. On Sunday, Tehran announced it would no longer honor stockpiling and processing limits on nuclear materials at the heart of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), the official name of the 2015 nuclear agreement. Though Trump withdrew the U.S. from the deal in May 2018, Iran’s decision is widely viewed as a deliberate escalation of tension aimed at the White House.

Leaders from the European Union, which is still a party to the nuclear deal and hopes to salvage it, determined Monday that Iran’s recent violations did not warrant the imposition of new sanctions.

As U.S. undersecretary of state for political affairs, Ambassador Wendy R. Sherman spent two years brokering the historic nuclear pact as lead negotiator for the U.S. She’s now director of the Center for Public Leadership at Harvard Kennedy School. Sherman discusses the tinderbox state of affairs between Iran and the U.S.



GAZETTE: There seem to be mixed signals coming out of Iran following the announcement. Foreign minister Mohammed Javad Zarif said Iran would continue to allow inspections by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). From your vantage point, where do things stand right now?

SHERMAN: Certainly, the Iranians saying that they will no longer respect the limits of action is not a good thing. Nonetheless, they have not formally withdrawn from the deal. They are allowing the IAEA inspectors to stay. They have said any steps they’ll take will be for technical needs and that they are all reversible, and that they would be open to returning to the deal if economic sanctions were lifted. So this isn’t good news, of course, but it could have been worse.

GAZETTE: In terms of preventing Iran from developing nuclear weapons, which was a primary goal of the JCPOA, is the world still under the deal’s umbrella protection or are we on the precipice of going back to where we started before there was a deal?

SHERMAN: I think the deal is hanging on by a very, very thin thread. And although Iran has said it’s ready to come back in, it appears that the Trump administration is doing everything it can to make it quite difficult for Iran to come to the table. The choice has always been a deal to keep Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon or an unrestricted nuclear program and a form of war. The president, for now, has chosen the latter.

GAZETTE: So there’s still room for diplomacy?

SHERMAN: There is still room for diplomacy, but there are no signs of diplomacy at the moment. The Trump administration seems to be on an escalatory path, particularly [with] the killing of Qassim Suleimani, and Iran will indeed respond. None of us quite know how or when that will happen. It will be asymmetric in its response and hopefully the administration will then try to open a channel for diplomacy as opposed to continuing an escalatory cycle, which would likely spiral out of control and find us at war.


"The United States has issued alerts for American citizens worldwide and, more specifically, in particular countries. So we are on greatly heightened alert all over the world, and it is of tremendous concern," said Ambassador Wendy R. Sherman.

Stephanie Mitchell/Harvard file photo

GAZETTE: What will be the determinative factor? Is it Trump’s behavior or the success of whoever is at the negotiating table or something else?

SHERMAN: There are multiple pieces here. Iran is not a good player here either. They have been attacking Americans. Interestingly, while the deal was fully in place, there were no rocket attacks by Iran. But since the president pulled out of the deal, those attacks and asymmetric actions of Iran have increased. The hardliners, or as I call them, the hard, hardliners, the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and the Quds force that Qassim Suleimani headed up, have been in control of Iran’s foreign policy and military policy and so Iran has been part of this escalatory cycle, as well. But the killing of Qassim Suleimani has accelerated this spiral quite considerably and how Iran responds and then how Trump responds to that will determine whether there’s any path back to a negotiating table or whether we are headed toward conflict.

GAZETTE: On Sunday, Secretary of State Pompeo described Iran’s calls for retaliation as “a little noise.” How likely is Iran to follow through on its threats and what kinds of actions would they likely have in mind to satisfy a desire for payback for Suleimani’s death?

SHERMAN:  They have said they would certainly take action against military sites of the United States, but added [Monday] that they are not limited to military sites. There’s some concern that they will use cyber as a tool. They have a lot of options on the ground. There are any number of soft targets around the world, including in our own country, that could see retaliation, so they will pick a time and place and method of their choosing, and they mean to keep everybody on guard as this proceeds forward. We’ve seen several countries issue alerts for their citizens. The United States has issued alerts for American citizens worldwide and, more specifically, in particular countries. So we are on greatly heightened alert all over the world, and it is of tremendous concern.

GAZETTE: Broadly, what are some of the immediate and longer-range dangers this situation poses to the U.S. and our allies? What are some of the potential worst-case scenarios?

SHERMAN: Clearly, the worst-case scenario is that we’re headed to war, and war would be horrific. The United States’ conventional capability is much greater than Iran’s. There’s no doubt about it. And so, in conventional terms, there’s no question we would win such a war. But Iran has many asymmetric capabilities, and we have seen in other theaters where we overmatched our opponents, our opponents sometimes use asymmetric warfare. It happened, quite frankly, in Vietnam, [and] that really makes it quite difficult for us to prevail in the way that we wish to. So I have no question about America’s military strength. We are unparalleled in conventional terms, and we can do any number of things. I do think, however, that the president’s tweets about cultural sites, about going after citizens after doing whatever he feels is necessary, is not only provocative, but, in many instances, [would be] illegal under international law and considered war crimes.

GAZETTE: Who benefits from a conflict with Iran? Oil prices are already up, and analysts predict they could double. China and Russia have harshly criticized the U.S. actions, more strongly than allies like the U.K. and France. Could we see an alliance of convenience between Russia, China, and Iran and what would that mean for the world?

SHERMAN: The alliance of convenience already exists, and it could grow deeper over this. So they stand to gain. But I don’t think anyone in the world stands to gain if there’s conflict in the Middle East because it will undermine the global economy as well the U.S. economy. I think it will have a downward effect for everyone. And obviously, there will be unintended consequences that none of us can imagine and quite terrible ones.

GAZETTE:  Clearly, this a very volatile, fast-moving situation that’s hard to predict.

SHERMAN: Yes, I think it will change dramatically. A month ago, there were anti-regime protesters in Iran; there were anti-Iranian protesters in Baghdad. Today, all of the protesters are anti-American. I don’t know how any of this has made the U.S. safer, as Secretary Pompeo said all day [Sunday]. It has not; it has made us all much more at risk. Ironically, President Trump has told us that he didn’t trust our intelligence community for months and months and months. And now, he says that the intelligence sent to him [persuaded him] to take this action, but he can’t tell us what that intelligence was. So we are in an upside-down world where I hope the U.S. Congress takes action to slow the president down before he hurls us into war.

This interview has been edited for clarity and condensed for length.


Wendy Sherman appointed professor and director at HKS东营干大盈商贸有限公司

Will succeed David Gergen at Center for Public Leadership

Inside the Iran nuclear deal楚雄义光复设备有限公司

Lead negotiator Wendy Sherman, now at the Kennedy School, explains how a key agreement was crafted

梦露直播app下载手机版 91视频污app在线下载 享爱app下载手机版 swag台湾污app在线下载 免费黃色直播app下载手机版 荔枝app下载手机版 富二代f2短视频app下载手机版 6房间视频直播污app在线下载 恋人直播污app在线下载 蚪音app污 佳丽直播视频app下载手机版 快猫视频污app在线下载 向日葵视频app污 樱桃app污 AVnightapp下载手机版 小猪视频污app在线下载 小米粒直播污app在线下载 豌豆直播app污 嘿嘿连载app污 7秒鱼app下载手机版 午夜直播间污app在线下载 么么直播app下载手机版 黄鱼视频污app在线下载 猫咪视频app污 69视频app污 丝瓜视频污污app在线下载 夜魅直播污app在线下载 音色短视频app下载手机版 内裤直播app污 烟花巷app下载手机版 IAVBOBOapp下载手机版 小小影视污app在线下载 音色短视频污app在线下载 黄鱼视频app下载手机版 番茄社区app下载手机版 烟花巷直播污app在线下载 后宫污app在线下载 咪咪直播app污 小草视频app污 小狐仙污app在线下载 盘他直播app污 小奶狗污app在线下载 夏娃直播app污 年轻人片app污 雨燕直播污app在线下载 恋人直播app下载手机版 向日葵视频app下载手机版 暖暖直播app污 夜夜直播污app在线下载 橙子视频污app在线下载 斗艳直播app下载手机版 年华直播app污 主播大秀app污 色秀直播污app在线下载 啪嗒视频app污 月夜直播app污 黄瓜视频app下载手机版 JAV名优馆app污 夜狼直播污app在线下载 骚虎直播app下载手机版 樱花app下载手机版 可乐视频app污 花仙子直播污app在线下载 富二代app下载手机版 享爱直播app污 快猫短视频app下载手机版 红高粱直播污app在线下载 9uu污app在线下载 d2天堂app下载手机版 MM直播app污 蓝精灵直播app污 花仙子直播app下载手机版 考拉直播app下载手机版 月色直播污app在线下载 樱桃直播污app在线下载 骚虎直播污app在线下载 丝瓜app下载手机版 夜狼直播app污 樱花视频污app在线下载 美梦视频app污 AVnight污app在线下载 福利直播app污 蜜桃app污 BB直播app污 番茄社区污app在线下载 7秒鱼直播app下载手机版 成版人茄子视频app下载手机版 快猫app下载手机版 彩色直播app污 富二代短视频app下载手机版 香蕉视频污app在线下载 麻豆传媒app下载手机版 豆奶抖音短视频app下载手机版 午夜直播污app在线下载 和欢视频污app在线下载 浪浪视频app污 丝瓜视频污app下载手机版 香蜜直播app下载手机版 91直播app下载手机版 享爱app下载手机版 萝卜视频app下载手机版 茄子直播污app在线下载 大秀直播污app在线下载 香草成视频人污app在线下载 小奶狗app下载手机版 享爱直播app污 成版人抖音app污 f2富二代污app在线下载 繁花直播污app在线下载 恋人直播app污 柠檬直播app污 黄瓜直播污app在线下载 富二代f2抖音污app在线下载 fi11含羞草app下载手机版 草鱼app污 享爱直播app污 成版人茄子视频app污 老王视频app下载手机版 免费黃色直播app污 91直播app下载手机版 主播福利app污 小狐仙视频app污 彩云直播app污 swag台湾污app在线下载 享爱污app在线下载 盘他污app在线下载 BB直播app污 花姬直播污app在线下载 蜜桃直播app污 泡芙短视频污app在线下载 91直播app污 茄子直播污app在线下载 望月直播app下载手机版 云雨直播app污 91香蕉污app在线下载 黄瓜视频污app在线下载 月色直播app污 青青草app污 花椒直播污app在线下载 bobo直播污app在线下载 6房间视频直播污app在线下载 黄页荔枝app下载手机版 樱桃app污 棉花糖直播污app在线下载 午夜直播app污 春水堂污app在线下载 薰衣草直播app下载手机版 花姿污app在线下载 尤蜜污app在线下载 小怪兽app下载手机版 香蕉视频app污 health2污app在线下载 秀儿直播app下载手机版 蚪音app污 水晶直播app污 蘑菇视频污app在线下载 梦幻直播app污 橙子视频污app在线下载 豆奶视频污app在线下载 蜜蜂视频app下载手机版 ML聚合直播app污 蜜橙视频污app在线下载 光棍影院app下载手机版 小姐姐直播app污 盘他直播app下载手机版 小奶狗污app在线下载 酷咪直播污app在线下载 最污直播app下载手机版 小草视频污app在线下载 黄页荔枝app污 年轻人片污app在线下载 佳丽直播视频污app在线下载 依恋直播app下载手机版 冈本视频app下载手机版 遇见直播app污 七仙女直播app污 丝瓜视频污app污 柠檬视频app污 月光直播污app在线下载 成版人茄子视频app下载手机版 茄子app污 杏吧直播app下载手机版 媚妹秀app下载手机版 猛虎视频app污 酷咪直播app污 七秒鱼直播app下载手机版 樱花污app在线下载 小花螺直播污app在线下载 草榴视频污app在线下载 兔子直播app污 抖阴直播app污 ML聚合app污 月亮视频污app在线下载 橘子视频app污 烟花直播app下载手机版